There Is Hope for Recovery from Thoracic Outlet Syndrome
I know how you feel... I felt the same way... now it’s time to feel better.
If you believe you are getting nowhere treating your thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS), I know how you feel. I suffered from chronic thoracic outlet syndrome, chronic neck pain, upper back pain, shoulder pain, nerve compression, and thoracic outlet syndrome for seven years. If I was a well-educated chiropractor from one of the finest schools in the nation and it took me seven years to figure out how to reverse thoracic outlet syndrome, then you know you are not alone in your plight. Many people living with neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome, chronic musculoskeletal pain, myofascial pain, and persistent nerve irritation experience the same frustration before finally finding the true cause of their symptoms.
I reversed my thoracic outlet syndrome, and it has been gone for almost 30 years. My recovery reinforced my belief that the body has an extraordinary ability to heal when the underlying biomechanical dysfunction, soft tissue restrictions, muscle imbalance, joint dysfunction, and compression of nerves and blood vessels are properly addressed.
Since discovering that the body is a spring and implementing the lessons taught in this book, I have been completely pain free for 25 years now. Understanding the principles of human biomechanics, movement mechanics, soft tissue restoration, fascial mobility, joint mobility, functional rehabilitation, and natural recovery changed not only my life but also the way I evaluate and treat patients.
Thousands Have Recovered from Thoracic Outlet Syndrome
Dr. Goldman and many others reversed their thoracic outlet syndrome. Their recoveries demonstrate that even long-standing chronic pain, neck pain, shoulder dysfunction, upper extremity pain, arm numbness, hand tingling, and thoracic outlet compression can improve when the underlying causes are properly identified and corrected.
When you read Dr. Robert Goldman’s story in the Foreword, there are thousands of similar patients who have found their way from chronic pain to a pain-free state, and so can you. Many of these individuals had been told they would simply have to live with their symptoms, yet they eventually restored normal function, mobility, strength, and quality of life through the correction of the underlying biomechanical and soft tissue problems.
So many of our patients with severe chronic thoracic outlet syndrome have been able to reverse it and get back to normal, healthy, pain-free living again. Go to www.thoracicoutletsyndrome.com and read the case studies. There are some incredibly interesting stories of how these patients suffered terribly yet overcame this difficult-to-reverse condition. I have seen the worst of the worst, including patients with severe nerve entrapment, brachial plexus compression, first rib dysfunction, scalene muscle tightness, pectoralis minor syndrome, postural dysfunction, chronic inflammation, and long-standing pain, and they have recovered from it.
The Biggest Challenges to Recovering from Thoracic Outlet Syndrome
What challenges do you face on your journey to rid yourself of thoracic outlet syndrome? Every patient encounters obstacles, but understanding those obstacles is often the first step toward successful recovery, rehabilitation, and long-term pain relief.
Many chiropractors, physical therapists, and manual therapists don't want to or can't perform the extensive deep tissue therapy, myofascial release, soft tissue mobilization, and manual therapy often required to restore normal biomechanics in severe cases of thoracic outlet syndrome.
Even if you gave this book to your chiropractor, physical therapist, or medical doctor and asked them to perform the deep tissue therapy I recommend in this book, there are three huge challenges to finding someone willing to perform 10–30 or more hours of deep tissue treatment, manual therapy, soft tissue rehabilitation, and myofascial treatment.
Challenge 1: The Physical Demands of Deep Tissue Therapy
The deep tissue therapy is extremely grueling on the hands and commonly causes hand strain, thumb injuries, wrist pain, repetitive strain injuries, overuse injuries, and other painful conditions for the chiropractor, physical therapist, or manual therapist performing the treatment.
Challenge 2: Time Limitations in Traditional Chiropractic Care
You must see a chiropractor for the first rib adjustment, but performing many hours of deep tissue therapy, myofascial release, soft tissue treatment, and manual rehabilitation is not part of a typical chiropractor's business plan. Most practices are structured around shorter appointments rather than prolonged hands-on treatment designed to restore normal biomechanics and reduce thoracic outlet compression.
Challenge 3: Insurance Restrictions on Manual Therapy
Even the best insurance plans limit the amount of manual therapy, soft tissue treatment, physical therapy, and rehabilitation that chiropractors and physical therapists can perform in one visit to approximately 45 minutes. Unfortunately, many patients with severe thoracic outlet syndrome, chronic soft tissue dysfunction, myofascial adhesions, and long-standing biomechanical problems often require substantially more hands-on treatment, deep tissue therapy, and functional rehabilitation than insurance reimbursement allows.
Challenge 1: Deep Tissue Therapy Causes Significant Hand and Upper Extremity Injuries in Healthcare Practitioners
The deep tissue therapy, manual therapy, and soft tissue mobilization required to treat patients with chronic thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) can be extremely grueling on the thumbs, hands, wrists, forearms, elbows, shoulders, neck, and entire upper extremity of the practitioner. The amount of sustained pressure, repetitive force, and prolonged manual treatment necessary can cause permanent injury, leading to disability of the chiropractor, physical therapist, physiotherapist, manual therapist, or other healthcare professional. Repetitive overuse injuries, occupational injuries, and work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WMSDs) are well-recognized risks associated with performing high-force hands-on therapy over many years.
Research on Work-Related Musculoskeletal Disorders in Physical Therapists
In 2016, a systematic review of work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WMSDs) among physical therapists, published in the Journal of Back and Musculoskeletal Rehabilitation, found that the neck, thumbs, upper back, and shoulders were common areas injured in physical therapists (1). The thumb strain, thumb overuse injury, and thumb pain were the most common work-related musculoskeletal disorders reported among physical therapists (10) (9) (8) (7) (6) (5) (4) (3) (2). These findings highlight the significant occupational risks associated with repetitive manual therapy, deep tissue massage, and soft tissue treatment techniques.
Thumb Pain is Extremely Common Among Manual Therapists
One study found work-related thumb pain in physiotherapists who regularly administer manual therapy techniques, joint mobilization, myofascial release, and other forms of hands-on treatment has been reported to range from 60% to 81% (4). This exceptionally high prevalence demonstrates how repetitive loading of the thumb joints, thumb ligaments, thumb tendons, and small joints of the hand can contribute to chronic occupational overuse injuries.
Many Practitioners Cannot Sustain the Demands of Treating Severe Thoracic Outlet Syndrome
If you have a serious or chronic thoracic outlet syndrome, many chiropractors, physical therapists, and manual therapists will not want to perform the many hours of deep tissue treatment, myofascial therapy, and manual soft tissue work that are often necessary. They experience the same chronic musculoskeletal pain, repetitive strain injuries, and occupational overuse disorders from performing intensive deep tissue treatments, including injuries to the wrists, hands, fingers (42.9 percent), shoulders (25.8 percent), and elbows (11.9 percent) (-).
The Vast Majority of Physical Therapists Experience Occupational Injuries
The majority (91%) of physical therapists reported that they had experienced work-related musculoskeletal disorders at some point during their careers. Additionally, 10.6% of therapists changed their specialty area of practice within the profession because of work-related musculoskeletal disorders (6), demonstrating that these occupational injuries can significantly affect career longevity, professional performance, and the ability to continue performing manual therapy.
Most Therapists Modify Their Techniques Rather Than Stop Treating Patients
Physiotherapists with thumb pain tended to modify their work practices rather than take time off work or change jobs, and only five (20.8%) physiotherapists in the Pain Group had sought treatment for their thumb pain (Table below). All physiotherapists in the Pain Group reported manual therapy techniques to be an initial cause as well as an aggravating factor for their thumb pain. Nearly all believed their thumb injury was related to patient load (92%) and the type of client treated (96%) (8). These findings emphasize the cumulative effects of repetitive manual therapy, deep tissue treatment, soft tissue mobilization, and prolonged hands-on patient care.
Out of 24 therapists that had thumb pain, this is what they had to do to continue working.
| Modification to Work Practices | Number | Percentage |
|---|---|---|
| A modification to work practices | 21 | 87.5% |
| Modified manual techniques | 21 | 87.5% |
| Avoided some manual techniques | 17 | 70.8% |
| Used different manual techniques | 12 | 50% |
| Permanently modified manual techniques | 8 | 33.3% |
| Used splints or taping | 8 | 33.3% |
| Decreased use of manual techniques | 7 | 29.2% |
| Permanently avoided some manual techniques | 5 | 20.8% |
| Used hand tools or ergonomic aids | 5 | 20.8% |
| Decreased work hours | 3 | 12.5% |
| Had time off work | 2 | 8.3% |
| Changed work settings | 1 | 4.2% |
| Changed jobs | 0 | 0% |
Graph comes from "Factors Related to Thumb Pain in Physiotherapists" — Snodgrass (8).
Challenge 1: Why Many Providers Do Not Perform Comprehensive Deep Tissue Manual Therapy
All of the above would have affected the treatment you would have received in their office. Unless they tell you, you won't know why your therapist or doctor does not want to perform manual therapy, deep tissue therapy, soft tissue mobilization, myofascial release, or trigger point therapy.
In most cases, it is because they cannot or do not want to due to the strain or pain in their thumbs, wrists, or shoulders, or they can generate more income by allowing assistants to perform less optimum therapies such as therapeutic ultrasound, electrical muscle stimulation, electrotherapy, or physical therapy modalities instead of performing prolonged hands-on treatment.
Many use tools like Grostic Technique, dry needling, and acupuncture. The problem with these therapies is that you cannot feel the muscle tension, muscle spasm, myofascial restriction, muscle tightness, or trigger points reducing with your hands, so you do not know whether you are actually breaking down the spasm or whether it has been completely released. Effective manual palpation provides valuable feedback that instrument-assisted techniques alone cannot always provide.
Another way providers avoid performing extensive deep tissue therapy is by starting you in rehabilitation exercises, strengthening exercises, therapeutic exercise, or resistance training, placing additional load and strain on your already compressed thoracic outlet, potentially increasing nerve compression, vascular compression, muscle tension, and your symptoms before the compression has been adequately reduced.
Some simply limit the amount of time they perform deep tissue massage, manual therapy, and trigger point release because they have too many patients, the work is physically demanding, your insurance only covers a few procedures of 15 minutes each, or their practice model is based on high patient volume. Remember, it usually takes 120–180 minutes to thoroughly address all 10 muscles contributing to thoracic outlet syndrome, neurovascular compression, and brachial plexus compression.
So, if your chiropractor or therapist has a chronic thumb, wrist, elbow, or shoulder condition from performing too much deep tissue massage, it is unlikely they will perform all of this intensive manual therapy on you for more than 15 minutes. Many providers are themselves suffering from thumb arthritis, carpal tunnel syndrome, tendinitis, elbow pain, shoulder pain, repetitive strain injuries, and even thoracic outlet syndrome. You might have to treat them!
Challenge 2: First Rib Adjustment and Comprehensive Thoracic Outlet Treatment
You must see a chiropractor for the first rib adjustment, but performing many hours of deep tissue manual therapy, myofascial release, and trigger point therapy is generally not part of a typical chiropractor's business model.
The reason surgeons remove the first rib is because it has been pulled upward into the thoracic outlet by a powerful contraction of the anterior scalene muscle, middle scalene muscle, and posterior scalene muscle. The posterior scalene muscle also pulls on the second rib and influences the alignment of the cervical spine and thoracic spine, helping elevate the first rib into the thoracic outlet tunnel, increasing thoracic outlet compression, brachial plexus compression, and vascular compression.
There are no muscles that can be exercised to pull the first and second ribs back down and out of the thoracic outlet. There is only one reliable way to reposition these ribs, and that is through a skilled manual adjustment, chiropractic adjustment, or first rib manipulation. You must see a highly skilled chiropractor for this specialized adjustment. Few chiropractors consistently perform an effective first rib adjustment. If you do not get this rib adjusted, you may never fully reverse your thoracic outlet syndrome, nerve compression, or vascular compression.
Why can't you receive both the first rib adjustment and several hours of deep tissue therapy from your chiropractor? Chiropractors often generate significantly more income by performing a quick spinal adjustment while their staff performs therapies such as therapeutic ultrasound, electrical muscle stimulation, or other physical therapy modalities. A spinal adjustment and rib adjustment performed by the doctor in three to five minutes, combined with staff-administered therapies, can generate approximately $100 per office visit. An efficient chiropractor may perform 8 to 10 adjustments per hour, allowing earnings of approximately $800–1,000 per hour.
It is unlikely you will find a chiropractor willing to give up $800–1,000 per hour to spend several hours performing physically demanding trigger point therapy, deep tissue massage, manual therapy, myofascial release, and soft tissue mobilization for a fraction of that income. Go to a chiropractor for the first rib adjustment, then either perform the massage yourself using the Vibeassage, Vibeassage Pro, or find someone with strong, durable, highly skilled hands who can provide the necessary treatment.
Many of my patients tell me there is no one in their area who wants to perform or is capable of delivering the powerful, comprehensive deep tissue therapy, manual therapy, trigger point release, and myofascial treatment they became accustomed to receiving with me. I find it difficult to believe there is no one qualified in those areas. If you find someone, please contact me and let me know who they are because we are always looking for highly skilled, strong, durable manual therapists, massage therapists, chiropractors, and soft tissue specialists who can provide this level of treatment.
Challenge 3: Insurance Limitations on Manual Therapy for Thoracic Outlet Syndrome
Even the best insurance plans limit the amount of manual therapy, soft tissue mobilization, myofascial release, and trigger point therapy that chiropractors and physical therapists can perform during one visit to approximately 45 minutes.
The Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) code 97140 is the billing code used for manual therapy. It is billed as one unit, representing 15 minutes of manual therapy, joint mobilization, soft tissue mobilization, or myofascial techniques. How many units would it take for the doctor to perform trigger point therapy on every muscle fiber of all 10 muscles compressing your thoracic outlet? If you have thoracic outlet syndrome on one side and it takes 120 minutes to thoroughly treat one side of your body, it would require eight units of CPT 97140 to address all of the muscles contributing to your thoracic outlet compression.
The problem is that even the best insurance companies generally allow a maximum of only three 15-minute units of CPT 97140 during each visit. That means you will require at least two or three visits simply to thoroughly treat all 10 muscles contributing to your thoracic outlet syndrome, brachial plexus compression, and neurovascular entrapment. If you have bilateral thoracic outlet syndrome, it may require five or six visits to perform one complete treatment of all 10 muscles on both sides.
If those muscles must be treated approximately 10 times before they completely relax, allowing full muscle relaxation, myofascial release, soft tissue decompression, and thoracic outlet decompression, you could require 20–30 treatments before your thoracic outlet syndrome is completely released. This assumes you consistently avoid breaking any of the postural correction, ergonomic, body mechanics, or activity modification rules that could increase muscle tension, nerve compression, and cause your condition to worsen.
Why Treating Thoracic Outlet Syndrome Yourself Can Be So Difficult
If chiropractors, physical therapists, and manual therapy specialists strain to treat these myofascial trigger points, muscle knots, hypertonic muscles, and chronic muscle contractions, how are you going to do it yourself?
I haven’t gone to a chiropractor in six years since I got my powerful vibrating massager, percussion-free vibration therapy device, and muscle recovery tool. It isn’t going to help you adjust your ribs down, but it will reduce your muscle tension, muscle tightness, muscle guarding, myofascial restriction, and soft tissue tension immediately on the first application.
I tell people, “Smart people go to doctors with the skill set and tools to get the quickest results.” However, really smart people buy the doctor’s tool and do it cheaper themselves. If you have this vibration therapy device, muscle massage tool, soft tissue therapy device, or home recovery tool in your home, you can treat yourself three to four hours or more per day, if you like. Then after your condition has reversed, and you feel a little pain coming on, you can knock it out fast before it becomes a condition you need to see a doctor for. This approach allows you to begin treating musculoskeletal pain, muscle spasms, neck pain, shoulder pain, thoracic outlet syndrome symptoms, and soft tissue dysfunction early before they become more difficult to manage.
Unfortunately, my patients who get the massager never come to me again for treatment. Ever! I have lost so many patients because this massager replaces me. It gives them an effective self-treatment, home therapy, muscle recovery, and pain management solution that they can use whenever symptoms begin to return.
Hospitals and many doctors only use therapy if they can bill the insurance for it. Even if it gets patients better instantly, they won't use it. I know because I am at the conference expos demonstrating the therapy on them. They are all incredibly impressed with how much better they feel immediately after the application. They experience immediate improvements in muscle stiffness, range of motion, circulation, blood flow, soft tissue mobility, and pain relief.
Then they ask the question, “What code do you use to get paid by insurance?”
When I tell them there is no code, either they buy one for their home to use on themselves and their families or they walk away.
Conclusion
The top sports medicine doctors and those doctors who work in the professional sports, entertainment, and performance medicine industries don’t worry about the insurance because their patients pay for whatever gets them better faster or improves their performance, recovery, mobility, and physical function.
For a list of all the doctors that have the Vibeassage or Vibeassage Pro to treat you, go to www.massageassist.com. If you do not live in close proximity to our office in Chicago, this is what I recommend you do.
Your Thoracic Outlet Syndrome Treatment Options
Option 1 – Self-Help Manual Therapy
- Correct your bad posture habits and remember to stack and relax.
- Work on all 10 contracting muscles that are compressing your thoracic outlet, performing deep tissue massage, myofascial release, and soft tissue mobilization yourself or with the help of your spouse.
If this takes too long or is too difficult...
Option 2 – Self-Help Manual Therapy Plus a Powerful Vibrating Massager
- Correct your bad posture habits and remember to stack and relax.
- Work on all 10 contracting muscles that are compressing your thoracic outlet with the powerful vibrating massager, vibration therapy, and muscle recovery device, then follow up by doing the deep tissue massage, manual therapy, and soft tissue work yourself or with the help of your spouse.
If this takes too long or is too difficult...
Option 3 – Combine Self-Help with Professional Treatment
- Correct your bad posture habits and remember to stack and relax.
- Find a massage therapist, physical therapist, or chiropractor to perform manual therapy, deep tissue therapy, and who has a vibrational massager.
- Find a good chiropractor to adjust your ribs.
- Perform your self-massage, home therapy, and myofascial release at home.
- Use the powerful vibrational massager, vibration therapy device, and muscle recovery tool at home.
If this takes too long or is too difficult...
Option 4 – Contact Our Office and We Will Help You
312 858 0800 Office
teamdoctors@aol.com
Regardless of which option you choose, I am here to help you.
Sincerely,
Dr. James Stoxen DC, FSSEMM (hon), FSSEMM
How to Find Doctors That Use the Vibeassage Pro or Vibeassage
The best sports medicine, rehabilitation, physical therapy, chiropractic, and manual therapy doctors and therapists don’t worry about the insurance because their patients pay for whatever gets them better faster or improves their performance, recovery, mobility, and quality of life.
For a list of all the doctors that have the Vibeassage or Vibeassage Pro to treat you, go to www.massageassist.com. If you do not live in close proximity to our office in Chicago, this is what I recommend you do.
How to Find a Chiropractor in Your Area
Go to www.f4cp.com/findadoctor to find a chiropractor, spinal specialist, manual therapist, or musculoskeletal healthcare provider in your area.
We are making a list of all healthcare professionals who specialize in the treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome, nerve compression syndromes, neck pain, shoulder pain, upper extremity pain, and thoracic outlet rehabilitation. Please email us when you find a specialist that has helped you.
Success Stories
Please take the time to read the success stories, patient testimonials, and recovery stories at the end of the book. Also, please go to www.thoracicoutletsyndrome.org and read about my newest discoveries in the articles, watch my educational videos, video tutorials, and stay tuned for my next book in the Human Spring series covering thoracic outlet syndrome, biomechanics, posture correction, muscle recovery, and non-surgical pain relief.
Please write me at teamdoctors@aol.com and tell me your success story.